I would like to suggest increasing the atk/matk of these weaps similar to e weaps. Even with enchant, the atk/matk of these weaps, it seems that the effects are underwhelming when compared to E weaps. I know these weaps aren't meant or designed to replace e weaps, but just as it is described, it should at least be comparable to e weaps.
Examples (I did not even add the possible enchants for e weaps, but I considered the atk/matk bonus for shapeless enchant):
WL Dagger (500) vs shapeless magic dagger (400+200)=100 matk difference, but the stats of e weap is far better than the weap.
WL Staff (550) vs shapeless staff (450+200) = 100 matk difference.
Minstrel Guitar (535) vs shapeless guitar (420+350) = 235 attack difference.
Suggestion: Make the base matk/atk of these weaps equal to their e weaps counter part.
Examples (I did not even add the possible enchants for e weaps, but I considered the atk/matk bonus for shapeless enchant):
WL Dagger (500) vs shapeless magic dagger (400+200)=100 matk difference, but the stats of e weap is far better than the weap.
WL Staff (550) vs shapeless staff (450+200) = 100 matk difference.
Minstrel Guitar (535) vs shapeless guitar (420+350) = 235 attack difference.
Suggestion: Make the base matk/atk of these weaps equal to their e weaps counter part.